spacer graphic   Kody's Version of LPG
aka Kody's Simple Swing
endcurve graphic
    midcurve graphic  

Home Page

Valid Criticisms of Traditional Golf

Endorsements for Teaching Methods

Endorsements for Literary Works



New Fundamentals
Instruction Manual:

Preface
(Available)

1. Very Crucial Necessary Concept (Must Order)

2. Merry-Go-Round Still Lives
plus Some Helpful Golf Sketches
(Available)

3. Tips and Addendums (Must Order)

Important Principal (Available)

4. Swinging Your Arms (Must Order)

5. The Bod's the Clod (Must Order)

6. Putting (Must Order)

7. Chipping, Pitching, and Sand Play (Must Order)

8. Mental Game and Course Management (Must Order)

9. More Ways to Teach the Swing (Must Order)



Order Form


Message Board


Join TCWGIK

Links

 
VALID CRITICISMS OF TRADITIONAL GOLF

Conventional Golf Myths: Jack Kuykendall letter to Jeff Bryant, the president of the USGTF

Why You Won't See Jack on The Golf Channel: Jack Kuykendall letter to major golf publication

100 Years of Golf Theory (kuykendallgolf.com) by Jack Kuykendall



Excerpts from THE GREEN by Troon McAllister

"A minor miracle of fiction... completely convincing, wise, funny."
     Steven Pressfield, author of The Legend of Bagger Vance

"How good is it? I missed my tee time because I could not put the damned thing down."
     Bob Habbitt, Publisher

"The richly drawn characters are stand ins for all of us."
     Stewart Cink PGA Professional

"To think that THE GREEN is just about golf would be missing the point."
     Paula Newby Fraser, Triathelete

This work contains the most devastating criticisms of "Go see your PGA pro" golf that I have ever seen in any fictional account of golf.

Let me set the stage for you. The USA is badly undermanned in an upcoming match with Europe (Ryder Cup). They have recruited this unsavory golf hustler Eddie Cammaretti as their 12th man. They are visiting the White House and Eddie has just solved the long standing putting problem for the president. The president is most impressed.

"Do you know how many lessons I have had?" asked the president. "Yeah well, every golf instructor teaches the game different." Eddie bit into the apple and talked while chewing as though he was talking with a guy who was unclogging his toilet."

"One says the key is to keep your head down, another says just keep it still, another says its the biggest crock of shit myth in golf altogether. One guy is obsessed with the swing plane, another guy couldn't care less so long as you hold your shoulders properly. One guy tells you that getting the grip right is 90 per cent of the game, another says it's the stance.

"One guy tells you to remember fifteen different things as you're standing over the ball, another says to get your muscle memory in groove on the range and then just forget about it on the course." I could tell from the pained look on the Presidents face that he had heard all of these things at one time or another.

Eddie took another bite of the apple. "Sometimes the simplest answers are the most correct. All these instructors flinging bullshit out there right and left and the problem is each one thinks he's Jesus, thinks his way is the only way, and that everybody else is a complete schmuck who ought to have his certificate lifted."

"So every time you change teachers, you have to go through this fraternity hazing where you hit a bucket of balls while he watches shaking his head and rolling his eyes and wondering what total asshole told you to hit the ball that way, f'Chrsakes. Then you have to explain to him what the other guy explained to you, which is mostly a lot of New Age household physics, and he laughs because it's such crap, and then tells you why it's such utter crap, which he does by replacing it with his own brand of scientific horseshit, and that's about the time he says, "Look what we gotta do, we gotta completely take apart your swing and put it back together, unlearn all those bad habits. Now it's gonna hurt your game for awhile, but blah, blah and so on." He waved his apple around as he finished up, then took another bite.

"That's exactly what that asshole Firth said to me," Eastwood (the pres.) exclaimed, naming one of the members of the European Ryder Cup Team. Eddie nodded in sympathy. "So you start off your lessons with this damned clown shaken his head like you're the dumbest creature in God's universe on account a you fallin for the first guys line of bullshit, and you're embarrassed to even take a swing in front of this thirty and hour Nickllaus whose got you convinced you wasted the last three years of your golfing life."

It was as if he was plumbing Eastwood's (the president) deepest golfing insecurities and laying them bare right in front of him. "You ever teach anybody Eddie?" "Once in a while, but never for money." "How do you do it?" "I watch him hit a bucket. No matter how bad he hits, I nod a lot and grunt in approval. When he's all done, I say something like you know that's not bad at all. Couple adjustments here and there, you're gonna see a big improvement. You got any ice?"

Eastwood immediately turned and asked a nearby aide named Manual to get some ice. "Right away Mr President," the aide replies, while leaving. Eastwood quickly returns his attention to Eddie. "So right away the guy feels good about his game, he knows I am not going to criticize the hell out of him, he's comfortable and eager. He won't cringe before his next lesson, afraid it's gonna be another half hour of instructional mugging, which will make him feel like shit."

"We're gonna have fun, me and him, whacking balls, talking golf, me giving him pointers that actually help and not confuse and helpin' his improvements become an important part of his game." The President reacted, "You tellin' me you don't have your own brand of bullshit?" "'Course" answered Eddie, "but mine is different for each student. If he's fixated on keeping his head down, I tell him fine, just don't get obsessed with it. If he's worried about his swing plane, I tell him it's OK not to be perfect there as long as he does other things right.. So right away he relaxes, which is half the battle right there let me tell ya."


LASKODY COMMENTARY:

It is obvious that the author is describing a carousel and all the instruction available is designed to keep him on the carousel. The pundits you see on TV and "expert" commentators keep golfers on the carousel. Are we to believe that Eddie has the key off the carousel or is he simply a kinder and gentler carousel tender? A100 years of history in which the average golfer's score has not changed significantly convinces me that this is just another stop on the carousel.

If you are interested in solutions, then I have the following sites for you to visit:

scigolf.com
Jack Kuykendall's Scientific Magazine
Natural Golf Chat (from here you can talk to golfers like yourself, no one will try to sell you anything)

Note: "The Green" by Troon McAllister is available at Borders and amazon.com

 
 
spacer graphic bottomcurve graphic   Edward Laskody, Elaskody@nc.rr.com